13 December 2019

In Pakistan Hospital, It Was Lawyers vs. Doctors. 3 Patients Died.” (NY Times)

Clad in black suits, white shirts and black ties, hundreds of lawyers forced their way into the Lahore cardiology hospital, smashing windows and damaging equipment. Doctors ran for cover, and unattended, panicked patients ran for their lives. The hospital wards were littered with shards of glass and broken furniture.

Riot police used tear gas canisters, water cannons and batons to disperse the intruders. The melee at the hospital, the Punjab Institute of Cardiology, lasted for hours on Wednesday, shocking the country.

In the end, officials said, three patients died amid the chaos. And now at least 80 lawyers have been arrested by Pakistani authorities, while Prime Minister Imran Khan has ordered an investigation.

The lawyers said they were avenging an attack in November by doctors and staff of the hospital, after the lawyers demanded preferential treatment.

This is quite an absurd situation that has resulted in absolutely tragic consequences. Everywhere in the world, lawyers are held to higher standards. This kind of conduct from lawyers is unacceptable.

Taking a step back, though, I consider my reaction revealing. Professional pride appears to transcend national boundaries. Is there something, however, innate in the legal profession that justifies such expectations? I think so. Lawyers deal in norms that govern conduct in every sphere of life (at least in the modern state — and there is no reason to think that Pakistan is not a modern state). Those who had committed themselves to the study and execution of such norms enacted as laws should not transgress such boundaries.

Links Law Lawyers

Previous post
“The Curious Case of Aurelius Capital v Puerto Rico” An unlikely alliance has formed between Aurelius Capital (a distressed debt hedge fund) and people and political parties from Puerto Rico, both of
Next post
Class Action Lawsuit Brought by Families of Congolese Miners Against Major Tech Companies A lawsuit has been filed against Apple, Alphabet (parent company of Google), Dell, Microsoft, and Tesla for “knowingly benefiting from and aiding